Transvox - 2024 Highlights from the Archive
TransvoxJanuary 04, 202530:1248.37 MB

Transvox - 2024 Highlights from the Archive

This week, we look back at some of the recordings from 2024 which we think are noteworthy or where there is value for the community.

Subjects include:

  • Jenny, Resolutions and the year just finished
  • Helen Webberly and her career fighting for Trans health services
  • Ed Whelan and his book about trans+ surgeries
  • Dee Constantine and their colleague talking about adoption and fostering
  • Katie Munday talking about trans medicalisation and the ‘gay ideal’

Thanks to all our guests and I look forward to further inspiring and wonderful guests in 2025.

You can submit questions to gillian@transvox.co.uk

[00:00:07] Are you a person that makes resolutions? Are you one of those? Or do you not bother?

[00:00:11] No, because I know I wouldn't keep them. I don't think I've ever really... I have done things like

[00:00:17] started diets on New Year's Day, but I think that's more of anything of just after the Christmas

[00:00:21] period, after a blowout over Christmas. I've never really been one for resolutions. What about you?

[00:00:27] I think what happens is there's too much pressure on resolutions because then you need a lot of

[00:00:31] willpower to keep them through. However, like you say, it's a good gathering point.

[00:00:35] Yeah. And I will be starting a diet on the 6th of January, having said all that, but actually,

[00:00:40] it's really about health and fitness. I'm looking forward to some cold weather as well, because

[00:00:43] Christmas Day was, I have to say, it's the warmest Christmas day ever. I've known I was out there

[00:00:47] in my shorts and t-shirt, sunbathing myself, flip-flops on. Well, it doesn't take you, George,

[00:00:53] as much to get your tops off in the freezing weather. That is true, actually, I must admit.

[00:00:58] It was, but it was warm. It was very strange. I know we're going to be talking about transgender

[00:01:02] issues, but my god, climate issues are even more scary, I think. Yeah, I don't think so.

[00:01:07] Although, didn't one pope once, I don't know if it was this one, it was a couple of popes back

[00:01:12] on their Christmas speech, once said that they felt gender identity or transgender people were

[00:01:17] a bigger threat than global warming. That's right. I'm sure I read that, which made me feel quite

[00:01:22] powerful in a way. Well, okay. Well, let's have a think back over 2024 and think if there are any

[00:01:30] lessons to be learned before we turn our attention to 2025. Any thoughts about 2024?

[00:01:35] I suppose that the lesson to learn is we survived it, and that's always a good thing,

[00:01:39] because I think it's difficult now. Every year seems tricky for our community, doesn't it? It seems to be,

[00:01:44] and this year we were facing two general elections, and then we had the publication of the CAS report.

[00:01:51] It seemed a very difficult time, and the politics was very difficult around those elections,

[00:01:56] because suddenly our 1% of the population was being talked about constantly, and it got even

[00:02:04] more crazy in America. So it was good to have them over, and it was a one-on-all draw for my hopes and

[00:02:11] outcomes in this country, in America. But yeah, it's hard to think of much that was that positive for our

[00:02:19] community though.

[00:02:24] Yeah, I'm the kind of doctor that I hate inequality, unfairness. I worked a lot in sexual health,

[00:02:30] and when I was training it was in the 80s and 90s, when HIV was becoming really paramount, and sexually

[00:02:36] transmitted infections after that. So I worked a lot with that and saw a lot of discrimination there,

[00:02:42] obviously against homosexual men in particular, and also drug users and women in the sex industry.

[00:02:48] And I just hate it. I hate inequality. And then I was working in a GP practice in,

[00:02:53] up in a small valley in Wales. And I suppose that was my kind of, I don't expect it was,

[00:02:59] but it felt like my first transgender patients. And she was saying I'm a mature lady who'd never really

[00:03:05] been able to acknowledge her identity. It was always very hidden. And she asked me to help her,

[00:03:10] and I had no idea about it. No training, no experience, nothing.

[00:03:13] And so I looked into what to do. And what I was supposed to do was refer her to a clinic in London,

[00:03:20] where she had to get the train kind of wearing a dress. She'd never got the train out of Wales,

[00:03:24] and never mind to go to a clinic in London. And so I said, don't worry, I'll do it. I'm a doctor,

[00:03:29] I can, I'm sure I can look this up and learn how to do it. And so as I was looking it up and learning,

[00:03:35] I just came across so much awful, terrible stuff. It was, I was just shocked. And the worst thing was

[00:03:42] that it was my own profession that was dealing out the horribleness, this discrimination, the prejudice,

[00:03:48] the terrible things I was reading was being done by my own profession. And I was just shocked to the

[00:03:53] core. And actually, at the same time, I was, I'm very interested in digital and tech, technology,

[00:03:59] I just love it, always have done. And I was making my own website. And I made some pages on there

[00:04:04] dedicated to what I was learning about transgender healthcare. And that's how it took off, really.

[00:04:09] That's how my kind of work started. A simple couple of pages on a website,

[00:04:14] and a keen interest to learn more about this patient group. So there you go.

[00:04:19] So how would you characterize the difference between things that were going on back then

[00:04:22] and now? Because there are similarities because things are going, pendulum swings backwards and

[00:04:26] forwards. But I guess that was still the time of the real life experience, was it? Was that still

[00:04:30] going on at that stage? Yeah, sure. And that real life experience, and the kind of hoops that people

[00:04:36] were being expected to go through, in order to just simply be themselves, or to live their life as

[00:04:43] themselves, or even just to swap their hormone profile. When I started learning about it, it seemed

[00:04:49] like the most unnatural thing to do in the world to swap someone's hormone profile. But then as I

[00:04:54] learned, I'm like, you're simply like turning off testosterone and replacing it with estrogen, or

[00:04:59] turning off estrogen and replacing it with testosterone. And as I looked into it, I realized, actually,

[00:05:03] it's one of the most simplest things to do. It's just one or two black or white estrogen or

[00:05:08] testosterone. It was really very simple. But the hoops that people were being asked to go through,

[00:05:13] in terms of what have you done to live as a woman? How can you prove to the world that you are a woman?

[00:05:18] What steps have you taken? Who have you told? And then the other awful things like,

[00:05:22] what do you do in the bedroom? What do you watch privately on your computer? And I was like,

[00:05:27] hang on a minute, this is, what's this got to do with anything? And then the other side of it was

[00:05:32] the kind of, this must have come from somewhere. You must be feeling this because you were abused

[00:05:36] as a child or raped in the park. And I'm like, oh my goodness, this is just someone's identity.

[00:05:41] And I was just shocked at what I was reading. And the other thing I realized that it was just at

[00:05:46] that time that the Women Inequality Commission produced their report and they openly said that

[00:05:52] the NHS is failing transgender people. And I was like, now it's been acknowledged.

[00:05:56] Now we'll do something about it.

[00:05:58] We are much more on the cause of, cause of feminism than, than, than people really understand that,

[00:06:04] I think.

[00:06:05] I think if you talk to young people, they're, and the modern generations are going to be so

[00:06:10] much better. I can't, I almost can't wait for them to be the ones in absolute power, if you like.

[00:06:16] But if you speak to the younger generations, they're like, does it not bloody matter?

[00:06:18] Does it matter? Man, woman, trans woman, non-binary person. It doesn't matter. We're just people.

[00:06:25] We're just people. And whatever our identity is, whatever our body organs are, we're just equal.

[00:06:32] And maybe we made a very big mistake many years ago by segregating gender or even making this thing

[00:06:38] called gender. We're just people. And actually, and all people have hormones and those hormone profiles

[00:06:44] sometimes aren't quite right for how you feel and how you want to live your life and how you want your

[00:06:50] body to, to look in the mirror for you and to the outside world. And what's wrong with that?

[00:06:56] Nothing. So I do sometimes feel, I wish we hadn't done that whole gender thing. And then we wouldn't

[00:07:01] be in such a pickle. And then I live in, I like, I spent a lot of time in Spain and then the Spanish

[00:07:06] language is one of those ones where they have mail and field cups and plates and knives and forks.

[00:07:12] And then my old goodness. We've got a male plate of the female car.

[00:07:17] We should not forget about the beauty of diversity and the need for equality. And I think those two

[00:07:25] fundamental things, once you understand that diversity is beautiful and we don't all want to

[00:07:29] be the same, we don't want to be that white, male, cisgender, heterosexual person that you were just

[00:07:35] talking about. And we don't want to be that. I definitely don't want to be that. And then when we

[00:07:40] understand that people are beautifully diverse and beautifully different, and then we should,

[00:07:45] and everybody is equal and everybody should have the equal opportunity to live their life to the

[00:07:50] absolute fullest. And when they go to their grave, they should be able to look back and say,

[00:07:54] I had the best life I could possibly have had. Everybody is beautiful. And that there are minority

[00:08:01] groups, if you like, and they have been, as I said, labeled by the, by the Equality Act.

[00:08:05] And that we, we should be just aiming for embracing everybody as who they are. And I think that's where

[00:08:12] I'm trying to come from when the work that I do in, in increasing visibility, increasing education,

[00:08:18] just the ordinary person walking down the street who doesn't know anybody who lives their life in a

[00:08:23] wheelchair or doesn't know anybody who is trans or doesn't know anybody who's gay apart from that

[00:08:27] funny guy down the street. Do you know what I mean? And it's about bringing that normality,

[00:08:31] ordinary, and into the, into everyday lives. And that's what my work has been about, really.

[00:08:37] We're both agreeing. It's just how we get there. You see, my view is that you have to have leaders,

[00:08:40] you have to shape the, you have to shape the world, you have to shape the community,

[00:08:43] you have to have people that build a framework to allow that to happen.

[00:08:46] And I think showing people, ordinary trans people, is really important. They're not scary,

[00:08:52] they're just beautiful people like everybody else. And I think if we portray this vulnerability,

[00:08:57] vulnerability. And if you see NHS protocols and place protocols, education protocols,

[00:09:03] protect the vulnerable. And I'm like, they're not, maybe some of them are vulnerable.

[00:09:09] And maybe some cis people are vulnerable. And maybe some heterosexual people and homosexual

[00:09:13] people and black people and white people are vulnerable. But don't label trans people as vulnerable.

[00:09:18] But they are, there may be some that are vulnerable, but it's not because they're trans.

[00:09:23] It's because the world doesn't yet accept trans people fully. And the other...

[00:09:28] Can I jump in there? Because I think that's quite interesting. Two things. One, which is that

[00:09:32] we have this image of trans people, usually, as you say, trans women. And I think we, we forget that

[00:09:38] actually, there's a, I think the majority now is trans mask. And we, there isn't the fuss about that.

[00:09:43] There isn't, I know where the feminists just say they're misguided and that's just even more hateful

[00:09:47] argument than anything else really. But we forget that. And we also forget the non-binary community as well.

[00:09:53] Come back to non-binary issues as well, if you don't mind. But I think that's really important to say.

[00:09:57] And I like what you're saying there. I always say that we're not vulnerable. We're not special.

[00:10:01] We're a minority community and that's a different thing. And I think we have to be careful not to

[00:10:05] characterize ourselves as a vulnerable community. We are a minority community and that's it. And some

[00:10:10] of us are loud antsy and not the slightest bit vulnerable. And as you say, some people are,

[00:10:15] but we don't want to be special. I just want to live a life, have a great relationship,

[00:10:19] go on holidays, eat cake. They just want to live a normal life, I'm guessing.

[00:10:22] They just, well, don't we all? And that's the thing. We just all want to live our best life.

[00:10:29] And to persecute or be prejudiced or biased towards somebody because of their identity,

[00:10:36] if you do it for long enough, they hurt inside. And when you hurt inside, your mental health suffers,

[00:10:44] and your psychological health suffers, and your social ability suffers. And eventually it just goes

[00:10:51] down. And so the people that we see who have poor mental health or can't integrate into social

[00:10:57] society in the way that they've had the ability to do, it's because they've been battered for so long,

[00:11:03] ignored for so long, suppressed for so long.

[00:11:05] What's your message for the trans community?

[00:11:07] I think my message to the trans community is that I have never worked with a nicer, happier, better

[00:11:19] group of patients. If I put my doctor's hat on for a minute in the whole of my career,

[00:11:25] I've absolutely loved the people that I've met, that I've worked with. So undemanding, so humble,

[00:11:32] thankful. And in many ways, I feel sad that you have to be humble and so grateful for the tiniest

[00:11:38] bit of love or care that you're offered. And so undemanding. And I'm sorry that you're so

[00:11:43] undemanding. I want you to be more demanding and get what you deserve and get what you should have.

[00:11:48] But honestly, I've never worked with a better group of people. It really made my,

[00:11:53] my, the end of my career absolutely so rewarding. And just, I think, just keep,

[00:11:59] I don't say keep fighting, just keep on at achieving what you deserve, which is the same as

[00:12:07] what everybody else deserves for their health and for their life and their wellbeing, which is just to

[00:12:13] live your best life. You totally deserve it. You're totally beautiful. And just keep asking,

[00:12:19] because it's not a lot to ask for.

[00:12:21] Yeah. And the other thing that we talked about just briefly, and I'm just conscious of your time,

[00:12:24] because I've seen it rocketing past night. This is our 25 minute episode. This might be episode

[00:12:28] three. We didn't talk enough about non-binary people. I just wonder whether we say a few

[00:12:32] things. I often think the problem with that term is that it's not, it's neither, neither this nor

[00:12:36] that. It, it almost needs its own word. The wordsmiths need to create something, I think. I

[00:12:42] just wonder what your thoughts are on non-binary issues. Because I think they have a really awful

[00:12:48] place because at least we get victimized and abused and don't get any treatment. But that's invisible,

[00:12:55] aren't they? And it just strikes me that we need to raise the temperature on that for those people

[00:12:59] as well.

[00:13:00] Yeah. In many ways, they're not, that group of people aren't bullied as much as the trans women

[00:13:05] that we talked about. Trans women get bullied most, I feel. But like you said earlier, trans men are

[00:13:09] kind of ignored and they're just like, oh, that's stupid. If you want to do, if you want to negate your

[00:13:13] beautiful femininity, be a trans man, you're so stupid.

[00:13:16] Have all that power and wealth.

[00:13:17] Yeah, exactly. And then non-binary people are a bit scared, people are a bit not understanding.

[00:13:22] Some people are like, look, can't you just shut up for minutes while we just get used to the fact

[00:13:26] that you switch from one to the other. I can't cope with that in the middle bit. But you're right.

[00:13:31] And actually, it just makes me think that I've always, I hate boxes. I like, I hate saying gay

[00:13:36] people or homosexual people, even though I've said it a few times. I just think, just let everyone just be

[00:13:42] who they are. Why do we need all these labels? Are they helpful? Are they a hindrance? And I think in

[00:13:48] the future, with young people particularly, they'll be like, nothing to do with you. Just let me be.

[00:13:54] I don't need to tell you whether I'm male or female or non-binary or both or somewhere in the middle.

[00:13:59] Tomorrow I'm going to feel slightly different to the way I do today. Just absolutely nothing to do

[00:14:03] with you kind of thing. And I'm looking forward to that time. But in the meantime, we do need to

[00:14:08] understand gender identity better. And the fact that gender identity isn't one or the other.

[00:14:16] It's a whole spectrum. And I've seen the other beautiful thing that I've seen is trans, for

[00:14:21] example, trans women coming to me saying, I'm trans women, I'm female. And then a little way into

[00:14:25] their journey, they're like, do you know what? I still got a little bit of that masculinity to me

[00:14:31] that I'm missing a little bit. And everyone's like, oh my God, does that mean you're not trans?

[00:14:34] Oh my God. But it's like, oh, it's just a little bit further down the spectrum. And then in a few

[00:14:38] months time, you might feel a little bit differently. What's wrong with that? Nothing. So I hate these

[00:14:44] kind of labels, these boxes. Let's just make gender identities, sexuality, personality,

[00:14:50] all of those things. Let's just let us be fluid. Let us be who we are. And it might be different today

[00:14:55] and tomorrow. But just acceptance is what we need.

[00:15:00] On that note, I can't disagree with you anymore. So I'm just going to just surrender now and say,

[00:15:06] it's Helen rules. And that's absolutely fine. So look, thank you for spending so much time with us

[00:15:10] today. Maybe you can come back and record episode four with us sometime. I'd love that.

[00:15:15] I would love to. Let's put a date in the diary for next year, and we'll do that for sure.

[00:15:19] Thank you so much for having me on. I've really enjoyed chatting to you.

[00:15:22] Pleasure. You too.

[00:15:27] There needed to be a resource out there that just helped people when they're just starting to think

[00:15:32] about surgery, could be in their future, and they want to just have a clear overview of the options

[00:15:40] and the pros and cons to get them started. And so that's how I came to write the book,

[00:15:45] which is called Gender Confirmation Surgery, Guide for Trans and Non-Binary People. And it's a

[00:15:50] introduction to the main confirmation surgeries and just, yeah, the pros and cons. It's a starter.

[00:15:58] It's a place to start. It's not thorough kind of everything you'd need to know under the sun,

[00:16:03] because really I was finding when I was starting to look at surgery, I could find resources like that

[00:16:09] online and they were overwhelming to me. There was just too much information coming at me,

[00:16:14] too much for me to take in. And so that's why I kind of thought there needs to be something that is

[00:16:19] reliable, but also just stage one to thinking about it.

[00:16:24] So who is it for, would you say?

[00:16:27] Well, definitely for anyone who thinks surgery might be in their future.

[00:16:33] It doesn't have to be something that you're sure about yet. The book is definitely not

[00:16:40] implying that surgery is what all trans and non-binary people do. And it starts with a chapter which is

[00:16:47] just thinking about surgery. So if you're unsure, if you're thinking one of the surgeries might be

[00:16:52] right for you, but you don't feel 100% yet, there's an exercise in there for just teasing out for yourself

[00:16:59] to help you kind of sift through your thoughts. What do I want? What am I hoping for? What do I find

[00:17:06] difficult about this part of my body or that part of my body? And can surgery actually give me the thing

[00:17:12] that I want? Because it's very easy maybe to think. As certainly as I, I sort of dived into my transition

[00:17:20] and just sort of head down and just ploughed forward. And it was right for me, but I wasn't

[00:17:28] stopping very long to sort of really think about what I needed and wanted all the time. And I've

[00:17:34] certainly met other people who maybe rushed a little bit too fast and didn't have the time and space to

[00:17:40] think about what they wanted. And so surgeries has a lot of options. It's not always clear what those

[00:17:47] options are, but it can't solve everything either. It can't get necessarily solve everything that you

[00:17:53] find difficult about your body. It can't make you taller. Sorry? It can't make you taller.

[00:17:58] It can't make you taller. No. So I like the fact that you've got a sort of a thoughtful thing around

[00:18:06] whether surgery is right for you, because I think there is a risk with surgery and I've seen it

[00:18:11] on many programs and as a therapist myself, people get easily addicted to things and people can get

[00:18:17] addicted to surgeries, can't they? There's a sort of pursuit of something which can be, I guess,

[00:18:24] a risk which has to be mitigated in a way. Yeah. And I would hope that any surgeon that somebody

[00:18:32] goes for a consultation with would spend time talking to the prospective patient about what their hopes are

[00:18:40] for the surgery and whether that surgery itself can deliver that. But you don't get very long in a

[00:18:47] consultation. Maybe 45 minutes an hour. Wow, that's a long one. Yeah. Yeah. You know, maybe that,

[00:18:54] but maybe much less. And then maybe also you've been on the waiting list for several years to get to that

[00:18:59] point to have a consultation and you might have a lot of questions. You might also feel a lot of pressure

[00:19:05] on yourself to like, I've got to convince this surgeon that this is right for me because I'm never going to

[00:19:10] go back on the waiting list. So that's where like, I would always advocate, just spend time with

[00:19:17] yourself thinking about what you really need, what this surgery is going to give you, what it's going

[00:19:23] to affect in your social life, what it might affect in your sex life, what it's going to affect how you

[00:19:27] visualize your body and also really think about what it's not going to give you. And then just, yeah,

[00:19:33] if you can go in with those kind of realistic expectations of like, yeah, this surgery is right for

[00:19:37] me, but I also recognize it's not going to solve everything, then that can, that's a better

[00:19:43] chance that you're happy with the results. Hi. Yeah, I'm Dee. I use they learn pronouns and I am

[00:19:59] doing really good. I am a fostering recruitment officer from Southampton City Council and hopefully

[00:20:04] here to do a little bit of chatting about what that means and supporting people with kind of

[00:20:08] understanding the process of being assessed for foster care a bit more today. Great. And Carly, say hi.

[00:20:14] Hi, I'm Carly Arnold and I am the service lead for the fostering service in Southampton.

[00:20:22] So I manage the foster carers and the fostering team who look after kind of all of our vulnerable

[00:20:29] children in Southampton. Fantastic. Now, when you first started chatting, I was really quite,

[00:20:36] it hadn't crossed my imagination because I'm a little bit older than, you know, that fostering and

[00:20:41] adoption would be suitable, relevant, possible, practical for trans people, never mind the wider

[00:20:46] queer community. So when we first chatted about it, it sort of really opened my eyes. And so firstly,

[00:20:54] let's talk a little bit about fostering and adoption generally. And then let's talk a little bit about

[00:20:59] this world and what the specific challenges or pitfalls might be.

[00:21:03] So, I mean, what is the difference between a foster parent and an adoptive parent, for example,

[00:21:09] and why might you want to do it?

[00:21:12] I can answer that one, Dee. So obviously, so fostering is when we assess and have carers that work for the

[00:21:32] children, they support us in caring for those children. So Southampton City Council hold kind of parental

[00:21:42] responsibility for those children. Whereas if you were to adopt a child, the parental responsibility

[00:21:50] for those children would kind of transfer to those adopters. So they would then become that child's

[00:21:58] parents, if you like. And so that's kind of the difference, I suppose, between kind of fostering

[00:22:04] and adoption. And so we do have an adoption service in Southampton, and I don't manage that service as

[00:22:11] such. And so my kind of expertise around around the fostering aspect.

[00:22:17] I think also in an interesting way, kind of linking on to that point about self-actualization and self-identity,

[00:22:23] there's a really interesting strength, I think, that the trans community have in that we have often taken a

[00:22:30] very, very long process and a lot of deep self-reflection about our sense of self-identity.

[00:22:34] And we're often in, you know, certain places where actually we've kind of been there, done that and

[00:22:41] really kind of developed skills and strengths in having to do a lot of that work already that other

[00:22:47] people may not have ever encountered before. And it could be a really big strength for supporting

[00:22:52] young people in care who also need kind of support and development of their own sense of self and sense

[00:22:57] of identity and confidence in their lives. So I think that's a really interesting interplay that trans

[00:23:03] people have a unique perspective on.

[00:23:13] I think you wanted to kick the ball off by talking a little bit about trans-manicalization

[00:23:21] and some things around there. And also, I know we talk too infrequently about trans mask issues as

[00:23:28] well. So I don't know if there was something there you wanted to cover off. I can't remember what you

[00:23:31] said last time, but I'm sure as we get chatting, we'll be into all sorts of different issues. But

[00:23:36] where do you stand on trans-medicalization? What was your thought process there?

[00:23:44] Yeah, so I think it's probably a nice idea to summarize what trans-medicalization means.

[00:23:52] So basically, it's the idea that it's very much steeped in kind of

[00:23:59] cisgender ideals of what a man and a woman should look like. So there's this idea that trans people,

[00:24:12] in order to be actually legitimately 100% trans, that they have to either want or go through

[00:24:21] medical transition. And some people might call that full medical transition, where it's both top surgery

[00:24:29] and bottom surgery, and possibly middle surgery. So stuff like facial feminization and things like that.

[00:24:37] So there's a cohort of cisgender people, but also trans people as well, who are gatekeeping

[00:24:45] trans community, trans euphoria, trans joy for people who either can't access medical transition or

[00:24:54] don't want to in the first place. And I think that's pants. Basically, I feel like if trans and gender

[00:25:04] diverse people, if we've decided looking at colonial ideas of the gender binary is not for us,

[00:25:12] or what it is for us, but in our own certain roundabout, wiggly squiggly way, to then gatekeep

[00:25:20] other people away from that liberatory joy is, yeah, poor form.

[00:25:28] It's a peculiar argument, isn't it? Because I suppose, I mean, I came to this argument

[00:25:38] many, many years ago, because we were all called transsexuals in those days, because we didn't have

[00:25:43] the concept of transgenderism at that stage, perhaps. And so what happened was we had people who were

[00:25:50] having what we called, I'm doing the bunny ears at the moment, sex changes. And we were basically having

[00:25:55] people who were going through the operative processes. And, and of course, what happened

[00:26:00] is, was a massive kickback, because the government were then, of the day, were sort of fighting the

[00:26:04] case, why you would have all these people having sex changes, as it was said in the day, rather than

[00:26:10] funding cancer treatments. And so that age old argument came into practice. And so, and so, you know,

[00:26:18] it is a quite an interesting thing that the reason that we veered away from medicalization was this

[00:26:22] idea that we couldn't afford to do it, because actually the health budget for all these trans

[00:26:26] people, all, you know, there was going to be this wave of crashing wave of people who are going to

[00:26:31] want sex, sex changes, as it was said in the day. Of course, we never talked about trans men in those

[00:26:36] days, we only talked about trans women. That's where all the headlines are. And, and so I find it quite

[00:26:42] odd that in a sense that we, we were moved away from medicalization. Because actually going to be

[00:26:51] having a sort of a gender ideology and such like was quite convenient financially for the National

[00:26:55] Health Service at the time. But it's quite interesting that it's coming back that way now.

[00:26:59] But, but I'm fascinated by this idea that you said that it's coming from the trans community as well.

[00:27:03] So I often find that quite perplexing. So can you explore that a bit more?

[00:27:09] Yes. So I think there's a certain amount of gate, gatekeeping in queer and trans communities,

[00:27:16] spaces around legitimacy of queerness and transness, as if we need to do some tick box exercise in order

[00:27:32] for us to be queer enough or trans enough. And I think that's where it trips up a lot of people,

[00:27:40] people are being barred from community, but then are they communities that you want to be part of if,

[00:27:50] if, if, if they're exclusionary anyways. Yeah, I don't know. I find in queer spaces that I've been

[00:27:59] part of, there is still a hierarchy of gay men being the, the ideal queer person.

[00:28:12] You know, perhaps married with children. And there's still a hierarchy there and an idealism

[00:28:20] in some, in some spaces and for some queer people around what is an acceptable queer face.

[00:28:29] And that is around activism as well, you know, fighting for marriage equality and stuff like that.

[00:28:37] And absolutely, that's an important issue. But also, why, why would queer people say,

[00:28:45] say people who are polyamorous or asexual and stuff like that fight for the right to get married in a

[00:28:53] very, uh, heterosexual manner?

[00:29:00] Thanks for listening to this episode of Transvox. It's been a joy to have you with us. If you want to

[00:29:06] make contact with us, you can contact us at Jillian at transvox.co.uk and all of our money goes to our

[00:29:14] nominated charity. And Jen, you've chosen the charity for the next number of episodes. Which one have you

[00:29:20] chosen? Our charity is called Beyond Reflections, which is a charity that provides support and

[00:29:26] counselling to trans people, non-binary people and their friends and their families across the UK.

[00:29:32] An amazing charity doing some amazing work, really important. So please, if you can give.

[00:29:38] Great. And if you want to go and have a look at Beyond Reflections, it's beyond-reflections.org.uk.

[00:29:43] And, uh, but as I say, if you'd like to make a contribution to what we're doing, because we

[00:29:47] love to help the people who help us. Uh, again, if you've got ideas for, um, the show, things you'd

[00:29:52] like to ask us, questions, comments, applause, or, um, brickbats, feel free to send it all in to

[00:29:58] Jillian at transvox.co.uk. Until the next time, goodbye. Bye-bye.

[00:30:04] Bye-bye.

[00:30:05] Bye-bye.

[00:30:05] Thank you.